Watch those ads!

‘Son, what will you study in high school,” goes this honeyed voice over the car radio.

“Science and math, Mama’, answers a well-behaved sounding voice.

The conversation goes on.

“And later in college?”. ‘Mechanical engineering with a focus on mechatronics,’

 ‘Well then you must have XXX Fruits,” says Mama in her brightest voice, going on about how it helps children top the classroom.

Now I know it’s a bit daft to believe that ads tell the whole truth but there is a strong case to be made to monitor the claims they make. Particularly those for children’s food products because many people actually buy into them. Take the ads for Complan health drinks which many of us have grown up watching. For decades they have promised to add an extra 3-4 inches to a child’s height.

‘Mothers tell me things like my child is short so I give him Complan. They forget the child was small at birth, that the parents are small and some kids suffer critical illnesses post birth,’ says well-known pediatrician Dr R.K Anand, advisor and resource person for child care programs of international organizations like UNICEF. Dr Anand is a member of the Indian Academy of Pediatrics which has challenged Heinz, the maker of Complan, in court. “Would Heinz dare to advertise these claims as aggressively in the U.S, Canada or Europe?’ he asks. Heinz India says these claims are based on an internal study. But the point to note is that the study has not been registered under the Infant Milk Food Act as per law.

 Not just Complan, the IAP is now closely monitoring all advertisements promoting children’s products. “The commonest problem with children’s health in our country is malnutrition,’ says Dr Arun Bal, member of the Association for Consumer Action on Safety and Health. “The solutions are quite easy and cost-effective but when the products are advertised in an attractive format it makes parents more anxious”

“Poor families spend their hard-earned money on these products at the cost of their normal diet like pulses, dal and chapatis which is far more nutritious,’ adds Dr Anand.

World over, health claims made in advertisements for children’s food products are closely watched. In the U.S Nestle had to drop its claim that one of its products improved immunity after pressure from health authorities. In India too, the Advertising Standards Council has specific guidelines for such ads. About time they implemented them. ‘

6 thoughts on “Watch those ads!

  1. The ‘tall’ claims of the likes of COMPLAN need to be put through rigorous scientific scrutiny..but what is also worrisome is the total buying in of parents into this masquerade.If Bournvita, Fair and lovely and Complan have their way we would be a nation of tall,strong,intelligent and beautiful people .all out of a jar….like magic..

    • Absolutely. It’s time to really listen closely to what these ads promise. Certain juices we are told are as good as having a complete breakfast, biscuits that can subttitute for a meal, creams, shampoos. It would be laughable if so many did not believe in what they promised

  2. http://www.pledge-india.com/pledge.html a pledge made by 7 companies to create responsible food and beverage advertising to under 12 yr olds..but who is monitoring these pledges..self regulation has more often than not failed..and what of the others who ride piggy back on the advertising blitzkrieg of these mega monsters..only 7 companies want to be compliant?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s