Us and Them

Over the last week, newspapers and TV channels across India have widely reported the case of a 21-year-old student who has moved the Bombay High Court seeking permission to undergo a sex-change operation.

Bidhan Barua was to be operated on this month at a prominent Mumbai hospital.  After threats from his family, the hospital refused until they got a legal go-ahead. Bidhan wants to get operated as soon as possible because he wants to be with his partner. His father however believes the decision is “not just a personal one”, and insists Bidhan gets the permission of his grandparents and uncles. One newspaper quotes him as saying, ‘I gave birth to a son, not a eunuch’.

Bidhan’s decision is an intensely personal one, and I am full of admiration for this young man who has found the courage to come out into the open. Not easy in a society which is so quick to dismiss People-Not-Like-Us. And God help you if there is some sexual aspect to it.  My heart goes out to his family in Guwahati which no doubt is coping with awkward, even cruel, questions from neighbors and friends.

What I find appalling however are the comments I hear around me, some from fellow journalists. – ‘Now, how should we title the studio discussion? Daddy let me be a girl. No. I gave birth to a boy, not a eunuch!’’

Another comment,  “Where will he go for breasts? He is flat!”  Upon pointing out the sheer bigotry, I am told ,’Oh come on, how would YOU feel if your child wanted to do THAT?.

I am the first to admit that I will be less than enthusiastic. However it is finally an individual’s choice and a watershed moment for that one family. What gives any one of us  the right to pass judgment? Or comment on their lives?

7 thoughts on “Us and Them

  1. A schooling that still offers no sex education, and a legal system that is almost pushing for eligible age for sex between two consenting minors from 16 to 18.yrs.. .is ever going to produce citizenry that is sensitive to other sexual orientations and thus be open to individual choice making and choices..
    We are a nation of hetero sexists..and the bigoted remarks are a manifestation of that feeling that runs through us..

  2. I would even go far enough to wonder what standing the family has to interfere with Bidhan’s wish. Just because some people think some parts of your body decides your gender, psychology has proved rather.
    But I know, we are yet to get “there”. So I kinda agree with you. Bidhan and family need some privacy and people’s insensitive comments are not helping the situation.

    • The father’s remarks, as quoted, do come across as very, very cruel. I agree with you there. I guess it reflects how many os us feel we “own” our children, their bodies, their thoughts and their decisions. Bidhan has a tough, tough fight ahead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s